CCIV 110 WOMEN IN ANCIENT
GREECE
SPRING 2000
ILLUSTRATIONS AND STUDY QUESTIONS
HOMER, ILIAD
This
course is a discussion seminar. Thus, the reading
assignments for the course are relatively modest.
Students are expected to spend a significant proportion
of their class preparation time reviewing the
assigned reading, thinking about it, reading carefully the
material on the Web Sites for the assigned day, and
pondering issues raised by the reading and the background
material. The following illustrations and questions are
designed to help you get started.
Illustrations: Most of the illustrations present a
slightly different version of the myth or story than the one
that you will have encountered in the reading, and they are
intended to help you think "beyond the text": What happened
that we aren't told about? What are some of the questions
left open by the reading? What kinds of things would you
like to know that the text doesn't tell you?
Study Questions: The questions, like the
illustrations, are to help you get started. They raise a few
of the issues that we will want to discuss in class, but are
not intended to limit your thinking. Unlike the
illustrations, the study questions are tied closely to the
assigned texts. They are designed to help you think "inside
the text" about issues that need analysis, explanation, or
expansion; as you reflect on them, try to come up with ideas
of your own about issues you would like to bring up in class
for discussion.
January 31
Homer, Iliad, Book I
On the left, two heralds lead Briseis away from Achilles'
tent, one grasping her by the wrist. Does this betoken her
unwillingness to go? Achilles sits within his tent, and
raises his hand to his head, in a gesture of ritual
mourning. What do you think are the implications of this
gesture? Two unnamed companions watch Achilles. One of them
might be Patroclus, who was dispatched to fetch Briseis and
hand her over to the heralds. What is Patroclus' relation to
Achilles and why do you think he was chosen as Agamemnon's
ambassador? On the other
side of this cup, Briseis' arrival in Agamemnon's
camp is shown, although Agamemnon himself is not depicted.
Can you think of any reasons why not? To see an enlarged
representation, click on the image. The vase type on
which these scenes appear is a kylix. Link here for a
representation of this vase
shape. (From T. H. Carpenter, Art and Myth in
Ancient Greece [London and New York: Thames and
Hudson, 1991] #302; cf. H. A. Shapiro, Myth Into Art:
Poet and Painter in Classical Greece [London and New
York: Routledge, 1994] figs. 4, 5)
- The Iliad opens with a plague sent by Apollo,
and a quarrel between Agamemnon and Achilles. What is the
role, influence, power of women in this episode, which is
related in Book I, lines 8-412, and 510-580?
- Who is Thetis, and what is her relationship to
mortals on the one hands and gods on the other? Consider
especially the material in Book I, lines 413-510, and
587-637.
- What is the role, function, power, and influence of
the female divinities in Book I? Consider especially
lines 221-261, and 638-735.
February 2
Homer, Iliad, Book III
The abduction of Helen. On the left, Aeneas, the Trojan
hero, leads the procession, holding his shield. Next, Paris
leads Helen away, grasping her by the hand in the manner
seen on the preceding vase. This gesture is typical on
wedding vases, where the groom leads the bride away. Paris'
shield hangs on the wall behind him. Note the chair leg on
the far left, indicating that this is an interior scene.
Helen occupies the center of the composition, and she is
crowned by Eros (Love) flying by her head and Peitho
(Persuasion) behind her. To Peitho's right stands Aphrodite,
holding out her arms. (The identity of the boy on the right
is unknown.) How does this scene compare with the seduction
scene in Iliad Book III? Think about the differences
and similarities in details, and also about what you can
infer about Helen's attitude here from the character of her
representation. To see an enlarged representation, click
on the image. On the other side of this same vase, the
meeting of Menelaus and Helen after the fall of Troy is
shown. As in many representations of this scene, Menelaus
draws his sword, intending to kill Helen. But, according to
the legend, he caught sight of her breast and and dropped
his weapon. To see the a representation of both sides of the
vase from which this transcript is drawn, click
here. (From T. H. Carpenter, Art and Myth in
Ancient Greece [London and New York: Thames and
Hudson, 1991] #293; full vase from Margaret R. Scherer,
The Legends of Troy in Art and Literature
[London: Phaidon Press, 1963], #23, #98)
You can
read more about this vase on Perseus, and see color
representations of (1) Paris
abducting Helen; (2) Menelaus
attacking Helen; (3) a detail
of Paris and Helen.
- What is Helen's status and position among the
Trojans? Consider both what others say about her and what
she says about herself in Books III and in Book VI.
- What do you think is the relationship between the
duel at the beginning of Book III and the love-episode at
the end of it? Think about the differences and analogies
between love and war, and about how women figure in each
of these enterprises in the Iliad.
- What is the relationship between Helen and Paris
like? How does it compare with that between Achilles and
Briseis or Agamemnon and Chryseis?
- What does Menelaus say about Helen in the course of
Book III? How does this compare with what Paris says
about her or to her?
February 7
Homer, Iliad, Book VI
Hector conversing with Andromache before departing for
battle. To the left of the couple are Helen and Paris, and
to the right is Hector's squire, Kebriones, mounted on one
horse and leading another for Hector. Paris is wearing
winged shoes, presumably to indicate his arrival from the
battlefield as described in Book III. Link here to see on
Perseus (1) a color
representation of this vase, a detail
of the panel, and a drawing
of the panel; (2) a detail of Helen
and Paris; and (3) a detail of Hector
and Andromache. (Chalcidian black-figure;
Inscription painter; 540 bce). How does this scene
correspond with the departure of Hector as depicted in Book
VI? What is the effect of juxtaposing the two couples, and
of collapsing together scenes from Books III and VI? What do
you think about the differences in the representations of
Helen and Andromache? (From blank, "Title," Antike
Welt volume [date] page.)
- What are the various classes and groups of Trojan
women to whom you are introduced in the course of Book
VI? Who are they? What do they do? What is their
relationship to men in the poem? What is their role and
function as members of Trojan society?
- How would you characterize the relationship between
Hector and Andromache? Try to think about it from the
perspective of what you know so far about Homeric
society, which you have seen both from the perspective of
the Greek camp and the Trojan city.
- What is the function of Skamandrios (Astyanax) in the
scene between Hector and Andromache? Why do you think he
is brought to the wall? Would the relationship between
Hector and Andromache be different if they were not the
parents of Astyanax?
- Why do you think the meeting between Hector and
Andromache takes place at the walls of Troy rather than
in their home? Where does Hector encounter the other
members of his family whom he meets in the course of Book
VI? Is there any significance to their locations?
February 9
Homer, Iliad, Book XXII, Book XXIV lines 850-912
(pages 612-14)
Achilles about to drag the body of Hector around the
walls of Troy. As he mounts his chariot he looks back at
Priam and Hecuba, and Hecuba raises her hand to her head in
a gesture of mourning. Iris rushes toward Achilles, but the
standing charioteer is already urging the horses on. How
does this representation differ from the scene narrated in
the Iliad? On the right, the image of Patroclus leaps
from his tomb. What do you think this means and what do you
think it adds to the composition? To see an enlarged
representation, click on the image. Link here to see on
Perseus (1) a color
representation of this vase and a detail of
Priam
and Hecuba. (Boston 63.473; Attic black figure
hydria; archaic; 520-510 bce).
- Compare and contrast the appeals to Hector by Priam
and Hecuba in the opening section of Book XXII. How do
they differ and how are they similar? Does the order in
which they appear make any difference to their content?
How does what each says help to characterize him or her,
and how does it help you to understand the character of
Hector?
- Consider the lamentations of Priam and Hecuba on
pages 555-56. What does each say and how does that
compare with the earlier appeal of each? Does what each
says here cause you to change your mind in any way about
your answer to the first question above?
- Consider Andromache's lament and the introduction to
it on pages 556-58. What does this passage contribute to
the characterization of Andromache and to your
understanding of her relationship with Hector?
- Compare and contrast the lamentations of Andromache,
Hecuba and Helen at the end of Book XXIV. How does each
one add to the characterization of the figure in the
Iliad? Do you find out anything here about any of
them that you didn't know earlier? If so, what do you
think is the significance of the postponement of the
information? If not, what do you think the point is of
repeating here, at this point in the poem, details that
were given earlier?
Last Revised 16 January 2000
|